The Christmas Truce' - When Men Said No To War

[zengrifter]

The Christmas Truce' - When Men Said No To War
12-22-6 / Rense.com

On Christmas Day, 1914, in the first year of World War I, German, British, and French soldiers disobeyed their superiors and fraternized with "the enemy" along two-thirds of the Western Front. German troops held Christmas trees up out of the trenches with signs, "Merry Christmas." "You no shoot, we no shoot." Thousands of troops streamed across a no-man's land strewn with rotting corpses. They sang Chrismas carols, exchanged photographs of loved ones back home, shared rations, played football, even roasted some pigs. Soldiers embraced men they had been trying to kill a few short hours before. They agreed to warn each other if the top brass forced them to fire their weapons, and to aim high.

A shudder ran through the high command on either side. Here was disaster in the making: soldiers declaring their brotherhood with each other and refusing to fight. Generals on both sides declared this spontaneous peacemaking to be treasonous and subject to court martial. By March, 1915 the fraternization movement had been eradicated and the killing machine put back in full operation. By the time of the armistice in 1918, fifteen million would be slaughtered.

Not many people have heard the story of the Christmas Truce. Military leaders have not gone out of their way to publicize it. On Christmas Day, 1988, a story in the Boston Globe mentioned that a local FM radio host played "Christmas in the Trenches," a ballad about the Christmas Truce, several times and was startled by the effect. The song became the most requested recording during the holidays in Boston on several FM stations. "Even more startling than the number of requests I get is the reaction to the ballad afterward by callers who hadn't heard it before," said the radiohost. "They telephone me deeply moved, sometimes in tears, asking, `What the hell did I just hear?'"

I think I know why the callers were in tears. The Christmas Truce story goes against most of what we have been taught about people. It gives us a glimpse of the world as we wish it could be and says, "This really happened once." It reminds us of those thoughts we keep hidden away, out of range of the TV and newspaper stories that tell us how trivial and mean human life is. It is like hearing that our deepest wishes really are true: the world really could be different.

---------
Excerpted from David G. Stratman, We CAN Change the World: The Real Meaning of Everyday Life (New Democracy Books, 1991). Available for $3.00 from New Democracy Books, P.O. Box 427, Boston, MA 02130.

[mdlbj]

I wish we could find a way to do this now.

[Automatic Monkey]

Originally Posted by zengrifter

The Christmas Truce' - When Men Said No To War
12-22-6 / Rense.com

On Christmas Day, 1914, in the first year of World War I, German, British, and French soldiers disobeyed their superiors and fraternized with "the enemy" along two-thirds of the Western Front. German troops held Christmas trees up out of the trenches with signs, "Merry Christmas." "You no shoot, we no shoot." Thousands of troops streamed across a no-man's land strewn with rotting corpses. They sang Chrismas carols, exchanged photographs of loved ones back home, shared rations, played football, even roasted some pigs. Soldiers embraced men they had been trying to kill a few short hours before. They agreed to warn each other if the top brass forced them to fire their weapons, and to aim high.

It's a phony story. A German trying to write in English would never say "You no shoot..." That's how a southern or southeastern European would do it.

This has happened often in war, but it's usually at the end of a war when both sides know an armistice is imminent. It happened a lot towards the end of the War Between the States.

[shadroch]

Its not a phony story. It really happened.The remaining years of The Great War,the High Commands arrainged official truces so the spontaneous ones never had a chance of occuring.

[QFIT]

Originally Posted by Automatic Monkey

It's a phony story. A German trying to write in English would never say "You no shoot..." That's how a southern or southeastern European would do it.

Sounds like an Anglicization of a German making a poor attempt at the more complex French negative. That is, "Vous n'pas tirer" or "Vous non tirez" as opposed to "Ne tirer pas." Someone making an attempt at a language they don't know is likely to only state the pronoun, negation and unconjugated verb. (Which is all I can do in French)