zengrifter said:
A few of us are slow - it starts at 33%, then one is eliminated, this means that the odds are 50-50 for either remaining door - how do my odds improve by switching between the 50-50 doors?? zg
Ps - Earlier in the thread I was not alone in not getting it.
ok lets look at it this way first way by not switching you have a 33% change becuase there are only 3 doors.... ok are u still with us?
now lets look at the choice to switch you pick a door..
first option you have a 33% change you picked the right one
66% change you picked one of the other 2 doors which doesnt have the caar behind it......
so say you picked the car the first time both the remaining doors have goats behind so the host will show you one and you pick the other you lose.......
now say you pick one of the other 2 doors initally with goats behind a 66% chace... the host has to show you a goat and there is only 2 doors remaining a goat and a car so he must show the goat leaving the car.. so you switch and will win!!!!! this is the whole point that if you don't pick the right door first which is a 66% change if you have a chance to swtich after seeing the other goat you will win 100% of the time after this.
so in the case of 3 doors the only time you lose if you pick the car for your inital pick.
do you get it now????