Hence why the question about age was asked.

I have no worries about being carded for age verification so why would I need ID on me at the table? Why would it be "horrible" for me to leave my ID in the car? I have no reason to have it on me. There is no law that requires me to provide ID on demand except to law enforcement and the PB doesn't qualify in that regard. If you look like you are underage, that's a different story.......you will likely get ID'd by security when you walk in so you should have it on you if you want to get in the door.
If you read the OP.....he was asking if it was normal to have the PB ask for ID and then have the PB record his information down in writing. This implies that he wasn't just "verifying his age". If you want to turn over your ID that easily be my guest, but I won't give it to them so they can then BO/86 me AND THEN turn my info over to other stores. There's the "can of worms" that I don't want to open.