If you check in the extensive (invaluable) tables in Blackjack Attack, 3rd ed. you will see the equity that a player's 20 has against the various dealer's up card.
Some of the results are (surprisingly) counter-intuitive (to me); but I do not YET have tables for Span21, although I am working on it with a computer programmer/player.
Searching the approx. equities for how a 20 fares against all the dealer's upcards, I find that we need to look at the Best and Worst case scenarios.
Thus, extrapolating to the logical extremes, at the margins we find that, [using an 8 deck S17 game], the BEST and WORST situations are:
vs. the dealer's EIGHT and ACE respectively.
if the equity of a hand is -.50 or worse (larger negative number) then LATE SURRENDER is a good idea.
IN THIS CASE, we need to search for an equity that exceeds a 50% LOSS.
Naturally, in this case all equities are positive with a holding of 20, so the above does not apply.
if the equity of a hand is +.75 or better (larger positive number) then the mean result is a profit of a HALF a BET, so CASINO SURRENDER is a good idea.
IN THIS CASE, we need to search for an equity that exceeds a 50% PROFIT in order to NOT take the HALF WIN being proffered.
It should be obvious to the reader that if the net profit is less than 50% of the bet then acepting the automatic 1/2 win is a fine idea.
I note that Ploppies are absolutely certain to either never take Casino Surrender or badly misuse it.
Equity and profit (in % of bet) for all hands when holding a two card TWENTY at a zero True Count:
2 = .64 - 36 = + 28%
3 = .65 - 35 = + 30%
4 = .66 - 34 = + 32%
5 = .67 - 33 = + 34%
6 = .70 - 30 = + 40%
7 = .77 - 23 = + 54%
8 = .79 - 21 = + 58%
9 = .76 - 24 = + 52%
X = .56 - 44 = +12%
A = .60 - 40 = +20%
Our 20 is worth the MOST against an EIGHT = .79 meaning that the equity is .79 - .21 = .58 gives a massive 58% equity.
Our 20 is worth the LEAST against a TEN = .56 meaning that the equity is .56 - .44 = a modest 12% equity.
SO ... if this Casino Surrender was applied to ordinary BJ,
Basic Strategy would be to take the 1/2 WIN with a 20 against
ALL cards EXCEPT the the dealer's SEVEN, EIGHT or NINE.
Remember, in Span21, the % of Tens is 3/12 [8.33% x 3] = 25% while in BJ the % of Tens is 4/13 [7.77 x 4] = 31%
Showing a non-Face card, In Spanish 21, the dealer hits to 20 and 21 more often than in BJ - that should be obvious.
Also, In Span21, the dealer's overall bust rate does NOT drop as the True Count climbs.
I note that converting a "push" into a 1/2 win is a BIG DEAL, as it is a "swing" of 3/4 of a wager.
I think that this is more complex than it appears and as I do not have sufficient data for Spanish21 to delve into this problem, I am frustrated.
This still looks wrong to me and I have been puzzling over what I have presented here for the last hour.
ALL feedback will be very much appreciated