Cardcounter
Well-Known Member
here we go
88v7 is most costliest play, but because its so infrequent, my bet is on 12v7 over-all.
hmm, yeah i didn't consider the frequency for which the hand presents.![]()
When I asked the question I did not take freaquency into account that was not the question. Not Splitting 8,8 vs a 7 costs the player on average 64% of his orginal bet. Not hitting a 12 vs a 7 costs about 25%. Not hitting a 12 vs a 10 costs about 20%. Not hitting a 16 vs a 10 is a marginal play costs on average 3%.
hand probability:
12vs 7 (t,2 vs 7) 0.003677
8,8 vs 7 0.00044
16 vs 10 (t,6 vs 10) 0.014553
12 vs 10 (t,2 vs 10) 0.014553
You're underestimating the player hands.
Hard 12 can be made with T2, 93, 84, 75, as well as 2T, 39, 48, 57. Likewise, hard 16 is T6, 97, 79, 6T. 88 can only be made with 88.
I wouldn't think to look at the inverse hands in BJ as you would in craps where two dice can roll 3,4 or 4,3, but interesting thought.
But the point is, we're talking about "mistakes." None of us is going to make such a mistake frequently, if ever. Therefore, I don't think frequency should be part of the solution. On the other hand, splitting 8's should never come up. How can one forget to split 8's? To forget to split 8's, you must be three sails to the wind! Please don't drink and count.Here are the 6d,s17 numbers from the ev chart:
Which mistake is the biggest blackjack mistake in terms of EV?
Not hitting 12 vs a 7 (ev= -0.477)
not splitting 8,8 vs a 7 (ev= -0.48)
not hitting 16 vs 10 (ev= -0.536)
not hitting 12 vs a 10 (ev= -0.540)
Playing the hand correctly using BS:
12 vs 7, hit = ev -0.27
8,8 vs 7, split = ev +0.319
16 vs 10, stand= ev -0.54 / hit= ev -0.534
12 vs 10, hit= ev -0.375
than 8,8 vs 7 is clearly the largest mistake we could make.
hand probability:
12vs 7 (t,2 vs 7) 0.003677
8,8 vs 7 0.00044
16 vs 10 (t,6 vs 10) 0.014553
12 vs 10 (t,2 vs 10) 0.014553
based on frequency 12 vs 10 is the overall costliest mistake.
BJC
How can one forget to split 8's?
Priceless!This reminds me of my ploppy days. One of my friends could just not get down basic strategy, so we oversimplified it down to a few rules:
1. Hard hands
a. dealer 2, 3, hit to 13
b. dealer 4-6, hit to 12
c. dealer 7-A, hit to 17
d. double 11 vs. dealer 2-T
e. double 10 vs. dealer 2-9
2. Soft hands
a. hit to soft 18
b. double A3-A7 vs. dealer 5-6
3. Split hands
a. always split 8's
b. always split A's
c. don't split anything else
4. Insurance
a. NO
Despite all this, there wasn't a single rule on this list he didn't forget or screw up at one point, perhaps except insurance - not doubling 11 vs. dealer 6 ("Dealer 6 is bad, right?"), not splitting A's ("Soft hands hit to 17, right?"), etc.
Ironically, once he got BS down he became one of the best counters because he was the first one of us who could talk while keeping the count. We still mock him when we're at a BJ table together ... when dealer shows a 6, inevitably someone will ask, "dealer 6 is bad, right?"